Buổi 35: Writing Task 2 – Opinion: có nên bắt buộc học sinh làm tình nguyện? Văn phong học thuật nhất quán

There is a certain irony in the idea of compulsory voluntary work. Nevertheless, the proposal that every secondary school student should spend time serving their local community deserves serious consideration. In my view, the aim is entirely sound, but a rigid requirement is unlikely to achieve it; a flexible expectation, built into the school curriculum, would be more effective.

The benefits of community involvement for young people are considerable. Helping at a care home, a food bank or an environmental project exposes students to people and problems they might otherwise never encounter, and it can develop practical skills such as communication, responsibility and teamwork that are difficult to teach in a classroom. Advocates of compulsion also point out, with some justification, that if such work is optional, those who would benefit most are often the least likely to volunteer. A universal requirement ensures that the opportunity reaches everyone.

However, compulsion carries a significant risk: it can transform a meaningful experience into a tick-box exercise. Students who are forced to complete a fixed number of hours may approach the work with resentment, and organisations that receive reluctant volunteers may find them more of a burden than a help. More fundamentally, the value of voluntary work lies partly in the choice to do it. Removing that choice may undermine the very motivation the policy hopes to create.

A better approach, I would argue, is to make community service an expected and recognised part of school life without making it a condition of graduation. Schools could offer a range of placements, allow students to choose causes that matter to them, and give credit for reflection on the experience rather than simply for hours completed.

In conclusion, while I agree that all young people should have the chance to contribute to their communities, I believe that encouragement and choice are more likely than obligation to produce lasting commitment.

Riverside clean-up – Saturday 14 November, 8–11 am We are organising a morning litter pick along the river path near the office, together with a local residents' group. Gloves, bags and refreshments will be provided. Families are welcome. Taking part is entirely optional, and any amount of time you can give is appreciated. If you would like to join, please reply to this email by Wednesday so that we can plan equipment.